It is really hard to put into words how good this pizza actually is. No disrespect to Casey's General Store whatsoever, but you're not what was expected.
My mother-in-law lives in Reynolds, a good twenty-minute drive from home. Typically, we take IL 92 out towards Andalusia Road. You don't want to forget to grab snacks or beverages before you leave town, because once you get down IL 92, there is nowhere to stop unless you want to head back east into Milan...